I've been asked to write a few words on the Mozzies,
though Lord knows why, it isn't as if I am very good
at writing. But when the Official Chief Mozzilator
calls you must respond. A "few" words
might be optimistic though.
Perhaps this articles should be called Mozzies: the
Rise and Rise of a Promising Editor, charting my rapid
elevation through Runner Up Best New Editor through
to Best Regional Editor, Best Editall and onwards and
upwards with even more rapid progression via Most Long-Winded
to Most Peculiar (aka Funniest). And in all those contests
polling a total of just 4 people who would like to
meet me in person, and that includes two people I've
known for years.
What are these Mozzies? A bit of fun or serious motivational
tool or a pat on the back, recognition for a job well
done. Or maybe a popularity contest. Nah, I wouldn't
win anything if that were the case. Maybe a who shouts
loudest contest. There is probably some truth in that,
there are few editors nominated outside the World
categories I don't know of via the forums, and quite
a number
of World editors too. I think it likely that had I
not ventured into the forums and posted my first post,
first post anywhere in any forum by the way, and remained
quietly in the background editing away my efforts
would have gone completely unnoticed, at least Mozzie-wise.
Maybe a nomination for best stealth editor in 2004.
If that is the case, and I truly believe it is, maybe
they should be treated as just a bit of fun amongst
the noisy forum posters. But I think there is something
to be said for them as a motivator and recognition
tool. At least to begin with. Perhaps they are what
they mean to you personally at whatever stage you
are
at as an editor. Personally I enjoy nominating people
and this time around, saying why. It was probably
a good job that Most Evil Meta was a self-nomination
or I would have nominated lisagirl for hogging all
the chocolates.
It is a debate we should have though. Do these Mozzie
awards motivate you, or are they just a bit of fun?
For me, and many others,
the suspicion
is that they are just a little too official and too
serious at times. Particularly since turnout at less
than 5% even of active editors is pretty poor even
by modern democracy standards. Here's an idea for
next time - mandatory voting with a penalty
of 1000 edits if you fail to register a ballot.
Having said that, there is no doubt a lot of hard
(and serious)
work involved in organising and managing the contest.
But my decision to lower the tone, some might say
as far as the gutter, by running a commentary throughout,
was motivated by a desire to lighten the mood at
little. And of course seal the result of Most Long-Winded
beyond doubt - that category at least is a
serious business. But boy was that hard work, trying
to find
something vaguely interesting and slightly libelous
to say daily(ish), balancing it finely with the
desire not to be evicted from my editorship for
uncovering
the secret lives of the rich and famous. I hope
it provided some mild amusement to some, didn't
offend others too much, and encouraged voting rather
than put people off. And mapfan is back at home
now, all charges dropped.
Well some things were proven. Open voting seems to
make no difference whatsoever. Dead certs at the start
didn' t win everything in sight and some were
trounced well and truly. Except in Long-Winded of
course but then was that ever in any doubt? The Glittering
Ball went down well despite its location in a small
suburb of Brussels, and Gina Barbados hasn't
emerged from her Holiday Inn Express room even now.
Most people are happy with their haul from the Shopping
Editors' Supporters' Gift Catalogs.
Overall I think the Mozzies remain a welcome diversion
from routine editing - look at my logs, I didn't
do one edit throughout most of the process. You have
to face it, sometimes the serious discussions get
very boring indeed with pages of posts over the interpretation
of a single word in a category name and such like.
Sometimes we need to remember that no matter how
serious
the overall task we edit to enjoy ourselves and mingle
with like-minded souls. Some light relief doesn't
go astray.
Another benefit to the Mozzies is to highlight new
talent some of us may have noticed and some may not
have noticed. The likes of our new esteemed Best New
Editor. And some surprises all over the place, editors
I have never heard of before, even a meta I had never
heard of, scoring highly. Congratulations go to them
all, especially the new faces amongst the nominations,
runners up, and winners. But don't let it go to your
head! It is just a bit of fun after all! Or is it?
I am not sure why the powers that be asked me to write
this - except they had space to fill, and I can
fill space that's for sure. Though how much will
get through the censor I don't know. You would have
thought they would want the Most Sensible Editor
to
write a piece rather than little old me. I am not
even sure what I should be writing about! Anyway the
season
has ended and the candidates are already preparing
hard for the next ones later in the year. I have
a skeleton key for the Holiday Inn Express and will
be
joining Gina as soon as I have emailed this article.
The Admins have all returned to their bunker under
Yosemite, and the metas are saddled up and back on
the trail of miscreants. Except for a certain cute
lady who is finishing off all the leftover chocolates
first. Editalls are currently preparing themselves
for war over which is the best Sim game, and editors
are doing what editors do, editing. Heroes all and
long may that remain so.
DMOZ Free Press is looking for sponsors for the next season of Mozzies so any corrupt editors wanting to advertise their services are welcome to submit their details via the Report Abuse link on their dashboard, which I have borrowed specifically for the purpose.
- oneeye
|